Love and Theft and Covers and Parody
Friday, June 27th, 2008Usually I prefer to hear Bob Dylan sing his own songs in his own idiosyncratic voice. Recently, though, I’ve collected a few covers of his work that really got me to experience songs I already loved in new and interesting ways. These songs are by artists working in very different genres. They do all share with Bob Dylan an expansive knowledge of American music and a confidence in combining styles that wouldn’t always overlap, but that express their particular experiences of America.
I was going to try to link to these somehow, but in this case you can just look them up for yourself if you’re interested.
The Dixie Chicks, “Mississippi,” Top of the World Tour (Live)
This furious bluegrass-rock rendition of “Mississippi” weaves layers of defiance and skill and musical mixing into a compact message and summary of the group’s complex history. Apparently Bob Dylan wrote this for his album Time Out of Mind, but left it off and gave it to Sheryl Crow for her album The Globe Sessions. Then Dylan did use it on his album Love & Theft, in a rendition filled with regret and endurance, which I’ve loved since I first heard it. The Dixie Chicks’ version follows Crow’s arrangement closely, but this live performance surges with energy, and there’s that amazing little hoedown of banjo, fiddle and electric guitar near the end.
Taj Mahal & the Hula Blues, “All Along the Watchtower,” Hanapepe Dream
Hawaiian Blues, yes. Dylan’s own version and Jimi Hendrix’s famous cover howl with urgency. Taj Mahal has taken that tone inherent to the song and combined it with the resignation of the blues and the ancient saunter of island music. When he sings, “this is not our fate,” you do feel like he’s found some other path, but also like he could hold out up on that watchtower for quite a while if he needed to.
The Ramones, “My Back Pages,” Acid Eaters
Given that the Ramones managed to innovate by trying to take rock and roll back to the brilliant simplicity they loved, it makes sense for them to sing, “Ah, but I was so much older then; I’m younger than that now.” I probably like this punk cover better for its contrast with the Byrds’ chiming, celebratory rendition of this song. I downloaded both versions on my birthday last year.
Walk Hard
Also, I just got around to watching Walk Hard. The movie itself was mostly disappointing: good concept, good people, dull execution. The joke songs, though, were excellent, and the Dylan parody is brilliant:





